Because it seems to me there’s a specific set of problems there. It’s not just translating what was said in English into the language that they speak. It’s also about understanding the culture within which they speak that language, or am I overstating it?
This blog will record my journey through the US, Canada, Europe and home again (Australia) in search of best practice in consumer health literacy.
Saturday, March 23, 2013
amazing what you find
Because it seems to me there’s a specific set of problems there. It’s not just translating what was said in English into the language that they speak. It’s also about understanding the culture within which they speak that language, or am I overstating it?
Long time no post
But the debate continues.
What is health literacy? I know right. We are still asking the question. Which of the 17 or so definitions suits out need? The IOM definition doesn't quite capture it, still too much emphasis on individual skills and not enough of the barriers put up by the health care system. Health literacy is often, quite rightly, bundled up with the other social determinants (education, income, culture - all the things that make it less easy to be healthy). Health literacy it is a social determinant say some, it is socially determined say others (its both says Dr Rima Rudd!). And yet, all things being equal (i.e the social determinants have been cured) health literacy can be completely undermined the moment people are confronted with the health system.
I spoke to a group of medicare local folk a week or so ago. They want to promote after hours locum services to a public that has no idea the services exist, who think after hours doctors can't possible be as good as emergency services, that they would cost a fortune, that a doctor in your house in the middle of the night is kind of creepy. They have an image problem. So people take their sick and ailing bodies out into the chilly night and clog up emergency services instead. It's a health system in constant flux and the change is hard to keep up with. A colleague broke her shoulder, was sent by a GP to a hospital fracture clinic who told her the GP would need to make an appointment - and she wouldn't get in for some time. It was a week before she was able to see someone who was able to make a proper diagnosis and she had to pay for it.
My point, though slightly rambling, is that if health literacy is a social determinant, its the one social determinant that we, in the health sector, can impact. We can make our system more accessible. We can make it easier for people to know where to go, how to use our services, how to make appointments, when we might have to pay, when its free. I recall a report on women from African communities and health information, which concluded that women have quite reasonable health literacy but struggled with understanding the Australian health system. I know how they feel.
Tuesday, April 10, 2012
Walking in the shoes of others
Dr Rima Rudd told me a story once about the Len and Ceci Doak and their "first response" efforts after Hurricane Katrina in New Orleans. A tree of health literacy "experts" were at the ready to volunteer their efforts to make information that would reach communities in need, survival information, accessible information.
I really like that idea.
Next time I'll post on our forum - In their shoes.
Thursday, November 17, 2011
Health literacy and palliative care
Today I spoke to palliative care workers from across Victoria and this is the story I told.
As palliative care workers – and associated professionals, I’m sure that everyone wants to tell you their death and dying stories. So today I’m going to tell you mine and hopefully illustrate the role of health literacy in my family’s confrontation with the process of dying.
A decade ago my Dad was diagnosed with mesothelioma and died nine months later, he was 64. I recall that I often, quite accidently, referred to his palliative care worker as “the midwife”. I would ask mum, what time is the midwife coming, or dad, what did the midwife say? I didn’t think about it too much at the time, but in retrospect it occurs to me that midwives and palliative care professionals play very similar roles, guiding people through the big transitions – through pregnancy and birth on the one hand and death and dying on the other. One of the big differences between these two transitions, apart from the obvious - the potential joy inspired by the one event and the terrible sadness associated with the other - is the openness of communication and the flow of information.
There is so much information for women who are pregnant. There is a general hubbub of talk and chatter and gossip; there are endless books and brochures and web sites. There are telephone apps that tell you what your baby looks like week by week; there are bulletin boards, blogs and bibles – telling you how to manage from one stage to the next. Indeed, it’s probably fair to say that pregnant women - particularly white, middle class, Australian pregnant women - are subject information pollution. A plethora of opinion, comments, judgements and urban myth – from every which way; health professionals, family, friends and perfect strangers.
Dying on the other hand is the elephant in the room – in dying there is a silence of information and in that silence there often breeds great confusion, misunderstanding and misery. I am not suggesting that the information isn’t available, or that the books and brochures don’t exist, but it doesn’t flow with the same ease. I’m suggesting that the barriers to information that are everywhere across health and healthcare – barriers brought about by the many social determinants I mentioned earlier - are even more impenetrable when you add the reverence and fear and the cultural silence engendered by the process of dying.
My family is a typically dysfunctional Irish-Catholic brood of seven and each of us had our own strong reaction, opinion and understanding of my Dad’s condition and what it meant. My mother told us that dad was diagnosed with something called “miso something-or-other theloma” and it was lung cancer but it was only in his right shoulder. At one point she even threw in that it usually only affects tall people. We had no idea he had worked with asbestos, he did and he had also wondered over the years if it would eventually catch up with him.
Mum told us he would be able to live with “his condition” for years and that treating it would just make it spread and grow. The reality of course was that his prognosis was poor and treatment was just plain useless. My mum simply interpreted everything the doctors told them according to how she wanted things to be and God help us if we were to question it or suggest otherwise.
Dad said nothing. I think he knew he didn’t have long and was resigned to just quietly coming to terms with it and managing his death as best as he possible could. Deep down, Mum probably knew the reality too, but she nevertheless fully expected dad to continue unaffected, and despite the increasing doses of morphine, she would get frustrated because he forgot to pay bills or the put the bins out or water the garden.
Then there were the siblings; one brother tried to pack Dad off to Perth to participate in trials for a new treatment, a sister decided that the medical profession were lying to us and contacted them all to tell them so, another brother thought he could be treated with breathing exercises and another wanted to delay introducing oxygen because that was “giving in to the disease”. All of us fought over what was best at any given time. We wanted Dad to die at home but he (unsurprisingly) wanted to go to hospital. In his final hours, in a tiny hospital in South Australia, while my brothers drank themselves silly in the car park – Dad was still trying to manage his dying in his own way. His level of discomfort was so great that we asked the staff to increase his morphine but Dad, in his delirious state, said no, no more because he didn’t want his death to be . . . induced.
There was a whole other level of complexity because Dad was entitled to compensation but his case had to be heard while he was still alive. He was determined to do everything he could to make sure that Mum would be paid out before he died and so there were legal documents piled on top of medical forms and prescriptions, bills, appointment slips and instructions for a whole range of medical paraphernalia. We were all learning a whole new language that we had to master in a short time.
I thought Dad’s “midwife” was wonderful given what she had to deal with but nevertheless there are things that may have made our journey and therefore Dad’s journey a little easier. While grief was the overriding factor impacting our ability to function normally, each of us also brought different understandings within the different health literacy domains – and of course none of us was really willing to listen to the other and so really, it just got ugly.
What would have helped us? At the time I couldn't have told you, but in retrospect and with the benefit of hindsight and ten years of working in consumer health information, and the my recent whirlwind tour of the world this is what I can tell you:
- · Good, accessible, timely information about the disease delivered by a health professional to all of us. Information on what to expect, the prognosis, what the current treatments are and when treatment is actually useful. Information about the progression of the disease and how the dying is managed, when oxygen is introduced, the affects of morphine and how that can be managed etc., etc.
- · Good quality, interactive information online – maybe even the capacity to talk with other sufferers or families and facilitated by health professionals. My dad spent a lot of time on the internet searching for information and getting frustrated (a decade ago remember)
- · Information for all of us, family, partners, children and friends on how to support the dying and how to talk about dying, how to acknowledge the elephant in the room and its impact on everyone.
- · Information that is bite sized, accessible, easy to manage, with short, active sentences and limited medical language that can be read and shared with others. Information that refers to and directs readers to the evidence; to more complex information for those who need to go there.
- · Information about what is available in the community for the patient, for the family, as well as easy, accessible pathways to support and care.
- · Structured, inclusive, support sessions where all of the above takes place.
Thursday, September 22, 2011
patient satisfaction unsatisfying
Patient satisfaction surveys provide a way for patients to feedback on the quality of a hospital service. They are very influential because we take them very seriously. Wednesday, August 24, 2011
Bringing home the learning
It takes awhile to process a journey like the one I just had. And the processing is constant - every day the penny drops and then it drops again. For a moment I'm certain I have all the answers and then I have another epiphany. I've written so much about how we could apply some of the things that I have learnt - and I do keep coming back to the same themes (which I will talk about a bit later). But it's not so much about the interventions and strategies that we could adopt, it's how to make them fit, to slip smoothly into the many other pressing priorities of a major hospital - this is the challenge.
Thursday, June 23, 2011
Heading home
Flying home last week, via an unexpected and unwelcome detour to Sydney, I started to wonder how I might go about communicating the massive amount of information I have gathered. Health literacy is a poorly conceived notion in many ways. There are many definitions - all involving abilities and capacities to access, understand, communicate, use and evaluate health information. But the jury is very much out on what it is about health that is so tricky to access, understand, communicate, use and evaluate. Why is it that some people are able to manage relatively well? Is it cognitive ability, education levels, socio-economic status - empowerment, confidence? Or is it an increasingly complex health care system, together with an increase in chronic disease and the necessity for people to manage their own health. Is it a bit of all of those things? At the Health Literacy UK conference that I attended in Manchester, Don Nutbeam (health literacy guru in the UK) pointed out that the broader notion of literacy has struggled for a theory and measurement for many decades. So we needn't panic. The debate will continue and theories and measurements will come and go but in the meantime we need to apply what we do know and in doing so we need to feed the development of those theories and measurements. Thursday, June 9, 2011
Leeds - Wakefield - Yorkshire
Some great work going on at the University of Leeds. Particularly interested in some research with a critical health literacy bent. One study looking at the links between health literacy and women's decision making about pain relief during childbirth and another study about women, diet and exercise. Researchers here are also looking into diabetes, self management and some really interesting work on the information that comes with the various medical devices that people need to self manage. The findings, rather unsurprisingly found that the misuse of such devices can lead to incorrect readings. Really? (Said with irony!) And what are the consequences of having incorrect readings of your blood sugars and insulin? The European Union requires that information provided to patients passes a usability test but this kind of information slips through some kind of loop hole and is consequently excluded. Crazy.Wednesday, June 8, 2011
Turku - Finland
In the old Finnish capital of Turku, remnants of its former glory are tucked amongst many less elegant structures from the latter half of the last century. There are big cobblestone squares and buildings that have stood for so long they slouch. But there are also big soulless concrete blocks lining the city’s centre; functional, living spaces, businesses etc. But I saw very little of it really, beyond the well worn path from my hotel to the conference centre and the never-dark view from my window. And Turku needs time I think.
I was there for the International Health Promoting Hospitals Conference where a surprising number of doctors and senior hospital administrators, as well as a handful of academics and health promotion practitioners have gathered to nut out the role of the hospitals in promoting health as well as treating illness. The theme of the conference was salutogenesis – which, as I understand it, is a shift of focus from the risks of ill health to the resources for health. So rather than research what makes people take up smoking, consider what it is about the people who never take it up, or drives people to give it up. That’s it in a nutshell. Indeed it is rather similar to the way that Christina Zarcadoolis talks about health literacy. Let’s not focus on what is wrong with people – let’s find what is right about them and build our efforts to communicate around that.
At this conference, I was struck by how many of the health professionals, particularly the clinicians, had developed their interest in health promotion. It really was like a bolt from the blue, like they had suddenly started listening to their patients and realised that there was something wrong with the way that healthcare was being delivered. The classic “aha” moment, where the pieces all fall into place .
Some quotes . . .
“what is the point of treating these people over and over again without addressing the issues that are making them sick in the first place.”
“Health is no longer a thing of its own. It is connected and takes a part in shaping society”.
“The health care system has made massive gains in keeping people alive but not increasing healthy life years”.
It all makes sense – now for the mechanisms.
Tuesday, May 31, 2011
More from Jyvaskyla
Health promotion is firmly entrenched in the Central Finland Hospital District, though the team have hinted that there have been various battles for support, visibility and acceptance in the clinical environment. The universal struggle for resources and conflict over the relevance of health in a sickness environment. (And no, the picture is not of the hospital, I believe it's a soft drink company - I just liked the building)Monday, May 30, 2011
Jyvaskyla - Finland

Thursday, May 26, 2011
Netherlands
In Holland I had my find my way off the tourist track to Nijmegen and the Canisius-Wilhelmina Ziekenhuis Hospital. A humbling experience; finding the right money (I must get glasses), dropping the money, apologising for being so slow, asking if I was on the right train, not really understanding the answer so having to move to the another part of the train to ask the question again of someone else. Getting on the right bus (thank God), showing the driver the address that I had jotted down the night before, he shook his head and then laughed. He knew the address I'd just written it wrong. Humiliating. Found the hospital, all the signs in Dutch. Had been directed to go to a particular door which didn't seem to exist. Arrived at the front desk - thank goodness there was a friendly open face ready and willing to speak to me. Even better she knew who I was before I even had to speak. Sunday, May 22, 2011
London
In London I gave a taxi driver a sheet of paper with the address of my accomodation. He looked at it for a full two minutes before handing it back and saying, "I can't read that love". Later in a pharmacy, a woman and her adult daughter were contemplating the chocolate bars. The older of the two took a bar and said "this one, this is the slimming one". Her daughter tried in vain to explain that the bar had reduced sugar but that didn't mean it was actively going to make her slim. Mother refused to listen. Tuesday, May 17, 2011
Baltimore

So, Baltimore. Where the infant mortality rate is 13 per 1000 births. Just to put that in some kind of perspective, across the US the rate is 6.06 per 1000 births. In Australia it's 4.61 per 1000 births and even in our Aboriginal population it's 4.4. The measure of infant mortality is the pulse, blood pressure and temperature of a nation's health. So what's going on in Baltimore? Well, in only a few hours I wasn't going to pick up on all the social and cultural nuances but there are a few clues. For a start, 65% of the population is African American, a population who continue to be a disenfranchised, disempowered and extremely disadvantaged. They lack money, education and opportunity. There are more teen mums, more drug use, more alcoholism. In the naughties - studies found that the infant mortality rate was due to low birth weight babies which could be directly attributable to lack of prenatal care, malnutrition, lack of calcium, folic acid, magnesium and iron. African American women tend to not to breastfeed and a lack of proper bedding and information about safe sleep practices made babies more susceptible to SIDS. Campaigns across the States had a big impact on reducing SIDS amongst the white American population but the rates amongst African Americans remained
More on the US
I want to write about Baltimore though I was there more than two weeks ago now. And there lies the problem with such a whirlwind adventure, it can move way too quickly and the complex pieces fall into place a little too slowly. Now I find myself in London still deeply reflecting on my time in the US and next week I'll be in Amsterdam probably thinking about London and so it goes. The US left me gasping for breath. There, health literacy can be a calling more than a concept. Dean Schillnger at the IHA conference said something to the effect that the health literacy movement are the people who are driven to change the inverse care law - where healthcare is inversely proportional to healthcare need. He then quoted Jerry Garcia (remember, The Grateful Dead?) who said "somebody has to do something and it's just incredibly pathetic that it has to be us". Because who are we in the US? We are a handful of renegade doctors and researchers, some fabulous health and education academics and a whole lot of driven and passionate nurses, librarians, adult education practitioners - people who have "community" running in their veins. And yet health literacy doesn't have a development framework in the US, well not in practice at least. Academics like Christina Zarcadoolis are definitely about engagement and Rima Rudd's work is about understanding the consumer experience but generally the notion of engagement is still relatively foreign amongst the people working in the field. The passion is focused on what we can do to help you rather than on how can we work collaboratively to decrease this communication chasm.
Saturday, May 7, 2011
Irvine California - Institute of Healthcare Advancement conference
Dean Schillinger brought along a really powerful couple of videos from young folk on food and eating. I found the second one particularly good.
- “The Corner: Jose Vadi” http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hbJdibxwcMY
- Death Recipe: Erica McMath Sheppard http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XmfFGn-R1CI
From AHRQ: Health Literacy Universal Precautions Toolkit http://www.ahrq.gov/qual/literacy/ The toolkit offers primary care practices a way to assess their services for health literacy considerations, raise awareness of the entire staff, and work on specific areas.
From HRSA: Unified Health Communication (UHC): Addressing Health Literacy, Cultural Competency, and Limited English Proficiency is free, on-line, go-at-your-own-pace training that has helped more than 4,000 health care professionals and students improve patient-provider communication.http://www.hrsa.gov/publichealth/healthliteracy/index.html
Heaps more but just wanting to throw some stuff at you while it's fresh.